Outline for "Losing Our Grip: Revisiting Saul Bellow's Seize the Day in Trump's America"
- Eric Anders
- Dec 14, 2024
- 3 min read
Updated: Dec 16, 2024
Introduction: Trauma, Relationality, and the Post-Holocaust Crisis of Meaning
Core Themes:
Seize the Day as a reflection of post-Holocaust existential despair and relational disintegration.
Adorno and Levi: The impossibility of meaning or poetry after Auschwitz, and its resonance with postmodernism.
Horkheimer and Adorno: The authoritarian personality as a post-Holocaust phenomenon.
Connecting Wilhelm's moral masochism and relational crisis to Trump's America:
The rupture of meaning and hope after Trump’s reelection.
Trump as an authoritarian arising not from postmodernism, but from the American right's cultural roots (Ken Burns’ America and the Holocaust as a framework).
Climate change as the existential threat of our era and Trump’s role in perpetuating denial and profligacy.
Trauma theory as a lens for exploring collective and individual crises of meaning.

Chapter 1: The Trump Cult and the Authoritarian Personality
Content:
Psychoanalytic frameworks for understanding Trumpism.
Horkheimer and Adorno on the authoritarian personality.
How the Trump phenomenon exemplifies a distinctly American authoritarianism rooted in history, culture, and economic systems.
Parallels between Wilhelm’s crisis and the relational disintegration in Trump’s America.
Chapter 2: Wilhelm, Moral Masochism, and the Crisis of Mitsein
Content:
Wilhelm as a case study in relational failure and moral masochism (drawing from Karen Horney).
The role of mitsein (being-with) in fostering healthy relationality and meaning.
Psychoanalytic interpretations of Wilhelm's paralysis in the face of existential threat.
Chapter 3: Feminist Critiques of Seize the Day
Content:
Exploring gendered foundations of relationality in Seize the Day.
Critiques of Wilhelm's failures through feminist psychoanalytic and relational lenses.
Embodied care and the intersections of gender, trauma, and relationality in Bellow’s narrative.
Chapter 4: Trauma in Individuals and Societies: A Theoretical Framework
Content:
Differentiating individual and collective trauma.
The psychological impact of cultural trauma, with parallels between the Holocaust and Trump’s America.
Linking historical trauma to contemporary existential crises like climate change.
Chapter 5: Treating Trauma: Toward a Practical Psychoanalytic Approach
Content:
Synthesizing approaches from Kohut (selfobject relations), Winnicott, Klein, Loewald, and Laplanche.
The importance of attachment theory in rebuilding relationality post-trauma.
Clinical approaches to moral masochism, disintegration, and restoring healthy relationality.
Chapter 6: Existential Threats: WWII, Trump, and Climate Change
Content:
Contrasting the existential threats of WWII (fascism, militaristic aggression) with the Trump era (climate change, political instability).
Trump’s complicity in perpetuating climate denial and cultural profligacy.
Lessons from history on how societies respond to existential threats.
Chapter 7: Trauma, Relationality, and the Search for Meaning in Seize the Day
Content:
A deep dive into Wilhelm’s inability to "seize the day" as a manifestation of relational and existential crisis.
Relating Wilhelm’s failures to broader cultural patterns in post-Trump America.
Trauma as a rupture in the capacity for meaning-making and relationality.
Chapter 8: Postmodernism, Relationality, and the Crisis of Meaning
Content:
Postmodernism as a response to the Holocaust and its implications for relationality.
Comparing postmodern loss of meaning with the crises of relationality in Trump’s America.
Adorno, Levi, and Derrida as guides to understanding the cultural ruptures of both eras.
Conclusion: Finding Hope Amidst Existential Ruptures
Core Themes:
Lessons from Seize the Day for navigating crises of meaning and relationality.
Restoring mitsein as the foundation for rebuilding hope and meaning.
Addressing climate change and cultural trauma through relational approaches.
Moving forward in a post-Trump world with an emphasis on resilience and connection.
This outline connects Bellow's themes to contemporary challenges, situating Seize the Day as a lens for understanding trauma, meaning, and relationality in a fractured world. Each chapter can build on existing blog posts or inspire new ones, ensuring coherence between the book and ongoing discourse.
Comentários